Service Model | Full-service consulting, covering every phase of the hiring process | Hybrid between Retained and Contingency Search | Assistance sourcing quality candidates according to client-defined parameters | Agency becomes the Employer of Record |
Focus | • “Get the job done right”
• Headhunting
• Quality of candidate
• Focus on passive candidates | • Targeting both active
and passive candidates | • Speed
• Quantity (vs. quality)
• Primarily limited to active job seekers, hence lower-level candidates | |
Relationship / Agency Exclusivity | Exclusive search,
entrusted to just one
recruiting agency. | Exclusive search, entrusted to just one recruiting agency. | Exclusive (one agency)
or non-exclusive (multiple agencies). | Exclusive (one agency) or non-exclusive (multiple agencies). |
Commitment Level | High commitment. Agency dedicates significant time and resources to this search; does not stop until position is filled. | Commitment level higher than the Contingency model, but not the same level of dedicated support as the Retained model. | No commitment; can stop working on it at any time.
Agencies usually work on many assignments simultaneously. | |
Industry Overall Fill Rates | 90-95%
Search firms generally do not agree to a project that they cannot fill. | 70-80% | 10-25% | N/A |
Ideal Uses | • Critical Hires
• Senior Hires
• Confidential Hires
• Urgent Hires
• Niche Skillset
• Unknown Market
• Difficult Location
• Multiple Vacancies
• $150-300K+ positions | • Mid-Level Positions
• Urgent Hires
• Large Volume of Hires
• Limited Number of Suitable Candidates
• $80K-250K positions | • Entry- to mid-level positions
• Large number of qualified candidates available on the market
• Up to $75K positions | |
Candidate Presentation | Choose from a shortlist of thoroughly interviewed and qualified candidates | Choose from a number of pre-screened and pre-qualified candidates | More candidates, typically
less qualified, quicker | |
Candidate Exclusivity | Will not present shortlisted candidates to more than one client simultaneously unless agreed to by all parties | | Agencies present the same candidate to multiple clients simultaneously | |
Pricing
(average industry pricing) | 33-50% of total compensation | 25-40% of total compensation | 20-30% of total compensation | Hourly bill rates / Conversion Fee varies |
Financial Structure
(Fee is a percentage based on candidate’s annual compensation) | Fee is paid in three installments:
1/3 to start the search
1/3 at presentation of short-listed candidates
1/3 upon successful placement | Upfront, non-refundable partial payment of the anticipated fee for placing a candidate. Remainder due upon successful placement. | Start Date / First day of employment of the candidate | Fee applies if/when candidate is converted (client wants to employ candidate directly after temporary period) |
Guarantee | Depending upon the negotiated fee | 90-day pro-rated replacement guarantee | 30-day full replacement guarantee | No guarantee |
Key Advantages | • Expertise through Search firm’s advisory role
• Focus on quality
• Efficiency
• Saves money
| | Focus on the logistics of candidate sourcing over in-depth analysis and strategy limits service cost
| |